Run time: 15-30mins
Age range: 3+
Investigate how buoyancy and displacement are related.
Notice correlations and connections between different phenomena.
They may not notice the water level changing at first. And they may notice other things that have changed, not listed here. The important thing is to encourage them to observe carefully and notice as many things as possible! Let them observe as much as possible on their own, first. Then, if needed, encourage them to look at the level of the water. Prompt them to think about how the water level now compares to the water level you marked previously.
Once you have observed that the boat sinks lower in the water as you add weights to it, and the water level in the container rises, it's time to think about how the weights, water level on the boat, and water level in the container are all connected!
A boat floats because it is held up by the force of the water pushing it upwards. As the boat sinks into the water, it pushes the water out of the way and the water pushes back. This force is called buoyancy.
The strength of this buoyancy force increases as more water is pushed out of the way (displaced). (See also EYS_floating_and_sinking.html.) As you add weights to the boat, the boat gets heavier, and the force of gravity pulls it lower in the water. This pushes more water out of the way, so the buoyancy force increases, until it is strong enough to hold up the heavier boat with the weights in.
You can see that the boat sinks lower in the water as more weights are added, by comparing the lines you marked on the side of the boat, marking where the water level came up to as more weights were added.
The level that the water comes up to on a ship is called the waterline. Real ships have lines marked on the side, called load lines or Plimsoll lines, to indicate how much weight they are carrying. If the water is up to the top line, the ship is carrying the maximum amount of weight it can safely carry.
Figure 1: By Brinki, CC BY-SA 2.0.
The water that the boat pushes out of the way can't just disappear – it has to go somewhere! For the water in the container, the only place it can go is to rise higher in the container and fill up more of it. You can see the water level in the container rising as you add weights to the boat, by comparing the lines you marked on the side of the container as you added more and more weights to the boat.
So, as you add weights to the boat, the boat sinks lower in the water. As the boat sinks lower, it pushed more water out of the way. That water has to go somewhere, so it fills up more of the container and the water level rises.
You can feel for yourself the buoyancy force from the water pushing back, when you push the balloon into the water. As you push the balloon, the water level in the container rises, and the force pushing back on the balloon gets stronger.
The harder you push against the balloon, the deeper it gets submerged in the water, the higher the water rises in the container, and the stronger the force you can feel pushing back.1 1Push hard enough, and you might displace enough water to overflow the container! Hope you remembered to lay out those towels!
How do scientists come up with new theories and hypotheses about how the world works? Often, it's by noticing different things that seem to happen together. Whenever more weights are added to the boat, the boat sinks lower in the water. Whenever the boat sinks lower, the water level in the container goes up. Noticing this correlation gives us a hint that there might be some connection between these three things: adding weights to the boat, the boat sinking lower in the water, and the water level in the container rising.
The balloon confirms the correlation we noticed with the boat. As we push the balloon lower into the water, the water level in the container rises. It also lets us notice another correlation: the deeper we push the balloon into the water, the harder the balloon pushes back.
You may have heard the phrase: "Correlation does not imply causation." When two things always seem to happen together, it's extremely tempting to believe one causes the other. E.g. that the boat sinking lower in the water is what causes the water level to rise.
But how do we know it isn't the other way around? Maybe it's the water level rising that causes the boat to sink lower. Or maybe neither one caused the other. After all, what really happened is that we added weights to the boat. Maybe it's adding weights that makes the water level rise, and nothing to do with the boat sinking lower.
In this case, our intuition is right: it is the boat sinking lower in the water that makes the water level rise, and not the other way around. In fact, we can easily test this: try pouring more water into the container. The water level in the container rises. Does the boat sink lower in the water?
But it's important to realise that, just because two things seem to always happen at the same time – they are correlated – it's not necessarily true that one causes the other.
2
2For example, the number of lawyers in Hawaii is very closely correlated with the consumption of mozzarella cheese in the US. When mozzarella consumption goes up, the number of Hawaiian lawyers goes up. When the number of lawyers decreases, mozzarella consumption decreases.
But it's very unlikely that eating more mozzarella cheese causes more layers to start work in Hawaii! (Or that a new lawyer starting work in Hawaii causes people to eat more mozzarella.)
This correlation is probably explained by the increase in mozzarella consumption, and the increase in the number of Hawaiian lawyers, both being caused by something else in common. Such as the US economy growing.
Noticing correlations is only the starting point. Spotting that the water level in the container rises when we add weights to the boat, doesn't explain why this happens. But once we notice this connection, we can start to come up with possible explanations.
If all we noticed was that the water level rose when we added weights to the boat, we might struggle to come up with any plausible explanation. But noticing the other correlation is helpful here: the boat also sinks lower as the weights are added,
We know from experience that heavier objects get pulled downwards harder by gravity: a heavy weight is harder to lift than a light one. So might expect the boat to be pulled downwards harder by gravity as we add weights to it, and sink lower in the water. But as it sinks lower in the water, it must be pushing the water out of the way. That water has to go somewhere! The only place it can go is to fill up more of the container. So the water level in the container rises.
It's important to realise that we don't know that this is the right explanation. It's a hypothesis. In science, coming up with a possible explanation – a hypothesis – is only the beginning. The next step is to think about how to test this hypothesis, to see if it's right or not. The Floating and Sinking experiment is a good example of testing hypotheses.
The the concepts of correlation and causation are too complex to explain to young children directly. But learning to observe closely, learning to spot everything that's going on, and thinking about how these might be connected, puts these concepts into practice. Which is more important than knowing what they're called!
If you try this experiment with your own children, I'd be very happy to hear feedback on what worked well, what didn't work well, whether it was easy to follow, whether the explanations were clear, or anything else. I will continue to edit and improve this page over time. You can post public feedback on this page using the form below, or send me an email.
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated. Clicking submit will open your email client and let you send your comment by email. By submitting your comment you agree to license the content under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.